Authentic Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria · Hagerstown, MD
Fresh ingredients. Family recipes. Homemade sauces and dough since 2000 — a place for everyone.
Pizza
Pasta
Subs
& More!
A warm, family-friendly dining room with beer & wine.
We Come
To You!
A new way to party
Cafe Italia will come to your location and make fresh, handcrafted pizzas right at your party. Watch the dough get stretched, sauced and topped before your pizzas are cooked fresh for you and your guests.
Perfect for:
Something for everyone
From authentic Italian favorites to Neapolitan and Sicilian pizza, subs, salads and more — there’s always something to love at Cafe Italia.
A local favorite since 2000
If you’ve been searching for a real Italian pizzeria and restaurant in the Hagerstown area, you’ve found it. Authentic homemade sauces, fresh dough and incredible Italian dishes will have you leaning back in your chair saying, “Now that’s Italian!”
Our Story →
“Always enjoy our visits — you’re treated like family.”
— Nancy M., Google review
What our guests say
“We just love this family-owned, friendly restaurant. Everything on the menu is very good. It’s not trying to be anything it’s not – just delicious food like someone’s mom might make, at reasonable prices, in a comfortable setting.”
— Blue Highways · Google review
“Steak and cheese best ever. 10/10… The roll was toasted, the steak was perfection, the cheese on point… the onion rings 10/10 for crunch and flavor. I’ll be going back!”
— Lizz O. · Google review
“Love Cafe Italia! Our favorite pizza and stromboli stop. There is a dish for every palate and desserts too… Family atmosphere, definitely recommend! You’re treated like family.”
— Nancy M. · Google review
“Even when we haven’t been in for a while, Mike remembered our drinks and favorite appetizer, the calamari. Everything about Cafe Italia is obviously made from the heart. We’ve never had a bad meal or service.”
— Nancy B. · Google review
“The best place for Italian food in Hagerstown. Bring your appetite! Servings are large enough to have a second meal. If you have a large order look at the cater servings!”
— HuDahala M. · Google review
“Everything we ordered from the pepperoni pizza to the spaghetti with meat sauce to a hamburger to the Mediterranean salad was delicious! Jaden our server was awesome, very attentive. We can’t wait to come back again!”
— Tiffany R. · Google review
“You wanted treated like family? Go here! You want to drool while waiting for your food? Go here! You want to eat so much because your taste buds are happy? Go here and you won’t be sorry!”
— Randy E. · Google review
“The Greek salad has a homemade Italian dressing which was so tasty! The chef made my pizza into a heart, which I thought was a sweet touch since it’s Valentine’s Day! Definitely check them out if you’re in Hagerstown!”
— Chastity C. · Google review
“I found a new FAVORITE in Hagerstown, Maryland. The veggie stromboli was delicious! Pepperoni pizza was delicious and the paninis are phenomenal. Great staff, great atmosphere!”
— L. W. · Google review
“Overall this is one of the best spaghetti dishes I have had. The service was outstanding. Waiter checked on us several times filling our drinks and making sure everything was ok. 5 stars!”
— Greg B. · Google review
